1 Timothy 5:19 – Finding the Facts

Do not entertain an accusation against an elder unless it is brought by two or three witnesses. 

Summary: Paul’s instruction to Timothy reveals another glimpse of Timothy’s role at Ephesus as well as providing a clear guideline for parsing complaints about church leaders.   

This passage is very specific and is directed personally to Timothy. 

That does not mean that there is not an underlying principle we should pay attention to. There is. 

What it does mean is that we have an opportunity to peek inside the relationship between Paul and Timothy, and at the same time, catch a glimpse of the relationship between Timothy and the church at Ephesus. 

In this verse, Paul is speaking directly to Timothy, man to man. 

Why is that significant? 

So far, Paul has commanded Timothy to command others what not to preach (1 Timothy 1:3,18). These are other people who consider themselves preachers. He has also instructed Timothy on the qualifications for overseers (NIV – also bishop, pastor, elder, or church leader in other translations). 

As we have discussed before, this places Timothy as an apprentice of sorts to Paul. It puts him at or near the apostolic level of authority in the church. 

If someone were to bring a complaint about an elder to the church, they would want to bring it to the highest authority they could, so that tells us something about Timothy’s position and authority. 

Then there is the content of the instruction itself. 

What is the standard for a complaint against a church leader? We have already read Paul’s words about the vetting of someone who wants to serve (1 Timothy 3:1-13). To be considered for any type of leadership role, a person’s understanding of the Gospel message is so essential that it goes without saying. However, the heart of a man cannot be assessed by intellectual assent. Paul’s criteria for church leaders speak not just to their knowledge, but to the fruit of their faith. 

If someone is called into leadership who does not bear the correct fruit, that is not the man’s fault for wanting to serve. That would reflect negligence on Timothy’s part, something that I doubt would ever cross Paul’s mind. So the assumption is that the church leaders are above reproach (1 Timothy 3:2). 

Has a church leader done something wrong? Paul is not suggesting that such things should be ignored. The facts are the facts, and all he wants to be sure of is that an accusation is based on facts, not opinions. 

Application: Faith and integrity are essential for church leaders.  

Food for Thought: How do clear guidelines about having at least two witnesses contribute to peace and unity in the church body?

Please click ‘’Continue Reading” for comments.

Continue reading “1 Timothy 5:19 – Finding the Facts”

1 Timothy 5:18 – Pay the Man

Picture of an ox treading the grain. (Grok)

For Scripture says, “Do not muzzle an ox while it is treading out the grain,” and “The worker deserves his wages.”

Summary: Paul uses an Old Testament farming law to make a blunt point about how the church should treat its leaders.  

We have spent a lot of time looking at how the church should manage its expenses when it comes to helping widows. Paul was incredibly careful, almost clinical, about making sure the church didn’t pass out free food to people who didn’t qualify.

Now, he turns his attention to a completely different line item in the church budget: paying the leaders.

In the verse just before this one, Paul says that the elders who direct the affairs of the church well are worthy of “double honor,” especially those whose work is preaching and teaching. Then, to back up his statement, he quotes two sources.

One source is the Old Testament law: “Do not muzzle an ox while it is treading out the grain” (Deuteronomy 25:4). The other source is actually Jesus himself, quoting a common-sense proverb: “The worker deserves his wages” (Luke 10:7).

Let’s look at the ox first.

Imagine you are a farmer two thousand years ago. You use an ox to walk in circles over your harvested wheat to separate the grain from the chaff. As the ox works, it sees food right at its feet. If you put a muzzle on that ox to keep it from eating any of the grain while it labors for you, you are being cruel. You are using its strength to feed yourself while denying the animal the very fruit of its own labor.

Even under the Old Testament law, God made a rule against that kind of cheapness.

Then Paul couples that farming image with a quote from Jesus about human workers. If a man comes to work in your field, you pay him. You don’t make excuses, you don’t shortchange him, and you don’t expect him to work for free out of the goodness of his heart.

Why does Paul have to say this to Timothy?

Human nature doesn’t change. Just like people have a tendency to take free food if the church offers it, people also have a tendency to want something for nothing.

It is easy for a congregation to look at an elder who is pouring his life into preaching and teaching and think, “Well, he is doing God’s work, so he should do it purely for the spiritual reward.” Meanwhile, the man is struggling to pay his bills and feed his family.

Paul is putting a stop to that kind of thinking. He is getting back down to those brass tacks we talked about earlier. If a man is laboring to feed us spiritually, the very least we can do is make sure he is fed physically.

It is a matter of common-sense. It is also a matter of love. 

Application: Support those who labor to teach you the truth. 

Food for Thought: Why do you think people sometimes expect spiritual leaders to work for less than they would earn in a secular job?

Please click ‘’Continue Reading” for comments.

Continue reading “1 Timothy 5:18 – Pay the Man”

1 Timothy 5:17 – Double Honor

Picture of a man leading a bible study (Grok)

The elders who direct the affairs of the church well are worthy of double honor, especially those whose work is preaching and teaching. 

Summary: Paul points us to the obligation we have in the body of Christ to honor those who serve the most.   

Here is an interesting fact: If we look back at 1 Timothy 3:1, the text reads: 

Here is a trustworthy saying: Whoever aspires to be an overseer desires a noble task.” (NIV)

Continue reading “1 Timothy 5:17 – Double Honor”

1 Timothy 5:16 – Free Food

A picture of a bowl of soup and two slices of bread on a wooden table. (Grok)

If any woman who is a believer has widows in her care, she should continue to help them and not let the church be burdened with them, so that the church can help those widows who are really in need.

Summary: Paul continues his instructions about caring for widows.   

One of the things I like about the Bible is the underlying common sense. 

God knows who we are. He knows our hearts and knows how we think. Nothing surprises him. So when Paul talks to the church about taking care of widows, he is not given to sentimentality. 

Continue reading “1 Timothy 5:16 – Free Food”

1 Timothy 5:15 – How God Sees, Part II

 Some have in fact already turned away to follow Satan.

Summary: Looking at this passage from the perspective of church discipline reveals both a need and a solution.   

In Part I of this meditation, we looked at how God sees us as if we were made of glass. He can see into the very center of our being. He knows what is in the closets of our minds, even the things we have forgotten are exposed to his eyes. God knows us better than we know ourselves. 

Continue reading “1 Timothy 5:15 – How God Sees, Part II”

1 Timothy 5:15 – How God Sees, Part I

 Some have in fact already turned away to follow Satan.

Summary: This passage provides an excellent opportunity to explore how God sees us and compare God’s view of humanity with our own.   

How do you react to Paul’s words in this passage? Does it feel like God is losing the battle and Satan is winning? Do you fear that someone is bound for hell who should have been saved? 

Continue reading “1 Timothy 5:15 – How God Sees, Part I”

1 Timothy 5:14 – Antidote

Picture of a candle flame, courtesy of Pixabay.

So I counsel younger widows to marry, to have children, to manage their homes and to give the enemy no opportunity for slander. 

Summary: Life is hard. Adam and Eve’s sin left us with a genetic defect that opened our eyes to sin (Genesis 3:5). In this passage, Paul provides an antidote.   

Paul’s missive to Timothy has so far ranged from passionately personal to highly technical. This section on caring for widows (1 Timothy 5:3-16) is one of the more technical aspects of his letter. 

Continue reading “1 Timothy 5:14 – Antidote”

1 Timothy 5:13 – Sound in the Faith

A greasy blob descends through clear water leaving a trail of contamination (Grok)

Besides, they get into the habit of being idle and going about from house to house. And not only do they become idlers, but also busybodies who talk nonsense, saying things they ought not to. 

Summary: This passage, at first glance, sounds like an offhand comment about bad behavior. Digging deeper, we find an existential threat beneath the surface.   

Our last meditation on 1 Timothy 12, “Serious Stuff,” emphasized the spiritual risk of turning our back on Jesus. In this verse, Paul talks about something that seems insignificant by comparison. In verse fourteen, he counsels young widows to do things that “give the enemy no opportunity for slander.” Finally, in verse fifteen, he notes that some have turned to follow Satan. 

Continue reading “1 Timothy 5:13 – Sound in the Faith”

1 Timothy 5:12 – Serious Stuff

A warning sign says "DANGER AHEAD" (Grok)

Thus they bring judgment on themselves, because they have broken their first pledge. 

Summary: This passage is an extremely blunt warning against turning our back on the Lord. 

One of the things that I find interesting about the Bible is not so much what it says, but what is not said. For example, an Old Testament prophet might be given a prophecy, but we, the readers, are not told what it is. Then later, when the prophet delivers the message, we hear the rest of the story (1 Kings 14:1-20). 

Continue reading “1 Timothy 5:12 – Serious Stuff”